JJ Wetherholt’s rookie season has been nothing short of a disappointment. At the same time, it ended on a slightly sour note.
Stepping back, there’s a lot to appreciate: Wetherholt debuted (and got married) on Opening Day at Busch Stadium. He quickly established himself as a key part of the team — exactly what St. Louis envisioned when they drafted him with the seventh overall pick out of West Virginia University in 2024.
Wetherholt, who turned 24 in September, played Gold Glove-caliber defense at second base. Although the Brewers’ Brice Turang beat him out for the actual Gold Glove Award, Wetherholt’s plus-23 Fielding Run Value ranked him second among any player in the Majors, sandwiched between NL MVP Pete Crow-Armstrong and Wetherholt’s middle partner Masyn Winner, according to Statcast.
Wetherholt was hardly alone in battling a second-half slump. The Cardinals were an average offensive team as a whole through June (100 wRC+, 15th in MLB), but after that point (86 wRC+, ahead of only the Angels). In Wetherholt’s case, he not only has to deal with the rigors of his first full MLB season, but also dealt with tendinitis in his right wrist, which landed him on the injured list for the first half of September and likely contributed to his .608 OPS since the All-Star break (compared to .755 previously).
That finish shouldn’t overshadow what came before it, which was an impressive offensive performance from a rookie just two years removed from college ball. Wetherholt has proven without a doubt that he can be an elite defensive player at the highest level, but here are three reasons to believe there will be better things to come from his bat.
1) Controls the strike zone
That’s crucial for any player, but especially a young one, and it’s a big reason why the Cardinals trust Wetherholt enough to immediately put him in the leadoff position, with just 138 professional games under his belt (47 in Triple-A). Wetherholt had a lot on his shoulders as a hot prospect looking to claw his way back into contention with a proud franchise, and he was facing a Major League game for the first time. This is a big leap.
And again: Wetherholt flatly refused to expand the zone. His 21.2% chase rate ranked in the 94th percentile, just below Juan Soto, Mike Trout and Mookie Betts. Wetherholt never hit more than 23.1% in any month until an injury-shortened September.
He was particularly effective against breaking balls. Of the 165 batters who have faced at least 300 breaking balls outside the zone, only veteran Taylor Ward and AL Rookie of the Year winner Kevin McGonigle have swung less than Wetherholt (17.5% vs. MLB average of 32.5%). Unless you’re going to fish for curveballs, sliders and sweepers out of the zone, you force the pitcher to challenge you with fastballs. Or you take the walks that Wetherholt did (10.3% BB rate, ranked in the 65th percentile).
If Wetherholt can maintain that level of discipline, he will have a high level as a Major Leaguer and more potential than that.
2) He gets the bat on the ball — with pop
No doubt helped by that batting eye, Wetherholt was adept at making contact in his rookie season. He came up empty on just 20.2% of his swings, which ranked in the 75th percentile of all Major League hitters. In a league with a 22.1% strikeout rate, Wetherholt K’d only 16.8% of the time.
Typically, there is a trade-off: players who hit the ball hard often run and hit more shots; Players who miss and take fewer shots tend to hit the ball less hard. In 2026, there were 49 qualifying hitters ranked 75th or better in both slugging rate and K-rate, and 41 of them were below average in slugging percentage. Of that group, only the Rays’ Yandy Díaz and the Guardians’ Chase DeLauter boast a better slugging percentage than Wetherholt’s 44.9%.
It follows that if you can put a lot of bat on the ball and hit it hard often when you do, you will be set up for success.
3) There’s more to his 2026 numbers than meets the eye
With a late-season slump dragging things down, Wetherholt’s new slash line doesn’t look all that impressive: .242/.339/.365. Given the muted offensive environment around the league and Busch Stadium’s status as a pitcher’s park, that still put him at 101 wRC+, a notch above league average, but the numbers don’t jump off the page.
This is perhaps a little misleading. Based on his strikeouts, walks and contact quality, Wetherholt had an expected batting average of .255 and an expected SLG of .435 (or 70 points higher than his actual SLG). Among the 246 eligible participants, none experienced a greater difference between these two numbers. Regarding middle infielders, Wetherholt’s xSLG put him above NL MVP finalist Turang (.428) and below Nationals All-Star CJ Abrams (.438), who walloped 33 homers.
Of course, some of that goes to Busch Stadium, which has the largest gap between expected and actual SLG (38 points) of any ballpark in 2026. Wetherholt, for his part, hit 100 points better on the road (.314) than at home (.414).
Wetherholt’s home court doesn’t change, so that could remain a handicap for him. Even so, it’s reasonable to expect more production from Wetherholt’s bat in his sophomore campaign.