...

Buster Posey’s case for the Baseball Hall of Fame

He had hoped to travel there with his son for a youth baseball tournament a few years ago, but those plans didn’t pan out. A large contingent of Giants officials traveled to the New York suburbs last summer to celebrate Jeff Kent’s induction into the Hall of Fame, but Posey was not among them; as the club’s president of baseball operations, he had to stay behind and prepare for the Trade Deadline.

Still, it’s highly likely that Posey will get a chance to visit the hallowed baseball grounds in the near future.

Posey led a group of newcomers on the 2027 Baseball Writers’ Association Hall of Fame ballot released Monday. Candidates, whose voting results are scheduled to be announced live on MLB Network on Jan. 19, must receive at least 75% of the vote to be elected.

Given his impressive credentials — three World Series championships, the 2012 National League MVP Award, an NL batting title, seven All-Star selections, five Silver Slugger Awards, a Gold Glove Award and a 2010 Player of the Year Award — Posey has a legitimate chance to be in the same category as only I Johnnie Main and Johnny Main. catchers will be elected to the Hall of Fame in their first year of eligibility.

“I think surrealism is overblown, but it’s really surreal,” Posey, 39, said in a phone interview. “When I think about something like that, I think about where my head went, I go back as far as I can remember to baseball, to my dad, to my sisters, to my friends.

“When you think about a potential honor like this, it’s hard not to think about all the people who have had such an impact on me and my career for almost 40 years of my life. Obviously, he’s been there with my wife from rookie ball to my entire career. It’s hard to put into words. It’s kind of an emotional thing. But it was very emotional to think about.”

Posey is already an icon in San Francisco, where he spent his entire 12-year career and served as the backbone of the Giants’ three World Series-winning teams in 2010, ’12 and ’14. His status as the greatest catcher in franchise history has long been assured, but getting a call from the Hall would place him in even greater limbo.

How does Posey feel about the chance to join baseball’s most exclusive fraternity?

“I guess we’ll see,” Posey said. “Obviously it’s out of my control. I think it would be an honor to be on the ballot.

“I’d say interesting and exciting. There’s a bit of an unknown. It’s something different. I think depending on how it shakes out one way or another, it has the potential to be a really cool experience. If not, I’m grateful for the recognition.”

Posey’s scoring stats aren’t necessarily anywhere close to those of other Hall of Famers — he has 1,500 hits, 158 home runs and 1,093 catches — but he’s 16th among catchers with 45 Wins per Change in Base2 and Base30 average. .831 OPS (129 OPS+).

His numbers are very similar to Mauer, who hit .306 with 143 homers and an .827 career OPS (124 OPS+) in 15 seasons for his hometown Twins. This should certainly bode well for Posey’s candidacy.

Like Mauer, Posey also suffered major career-limiting injuries. He was limited to just 45 games in 2011 after suffering a broken fibula and torn ligaments in his left ankle in a devastating home plate collision. He also missed time with concussions and a right hip injury and sat out the pandemic-shortened 2020 campaign after he and wife Kristen adopted premature twin girls.

Posey could have gone on to gain more volume, but he decided to retire after leading the Giants to a franchise-record 107 wins in 2021. Posey was just 34 years old at the time and was coming off a resurgent season, but he felt tired of the physical demands of catching and wanted to spend more time with his family.

“I was very relaxed,” Posey said. “I was very grateful that I had a good year in ’21 and I really felt like I kind of drained the tank. I say this humbly: I think I could have kept playing, but for us it felt like the right decision.”

Posey isn’t the only Giants legend to be nominated for the Hall of Fame this year. Bruce Bochy, Dusty Baker and Brian Sabean are also among the eight nominees on the Modern Baseball Era ballot for managers, executives and umpires, making it a strong possibility that many of the franchise’s greats will head to Cooperstown together next summer.

“It’s really fun to think about,” Posey said. “I have a lot of respect for all three of those guys. I know Boch and Sabes better than Dusty, but I’ve gotten to know Dusty over the years. Just three great baseball minds. I think all three deserve to be in the Hall of Fame. So I’ll be watching him closely. It would be an honor to know what it means to have them go to the game.”

Leave a Comment