Thursday’s AL and NL Most Valuable Player announcements will likely bring something we haven’t seen in six years.
The Yankees’ Aaron Judge and/or the Dodgers’ Shohei Ohtani have won the MVP award in each of the past five seasons. Hakim is not an AL MVP finalist this year. That distinction belongs to Astros slugger Yordan Alvarez, Rays superstar Junior Caminero and Royals Bobby Witt Jr., who will finish in the top four in MVP voting for the third year in a row.
Ohtani is on course for his fifth career MVP trophy and third in three seasons with the Dodgers, but the NL competition is extremely tough. Cubs shortstop Pete Crow-Armstrong appears to be the favorite after a stellar 2026 season, both offensively and defensively. And we can’t rule out Brewers second baseman Brice Turang, who continues to raise his game every year.
Here’s the case for each MVP Award finalist, presented in alphabetical order before the winners are announced at 7:00 PM ET on MLB Network.
Alvarez’s 2026 season was so dominant that even a severe drought in August didn’t stop him from putting up monstrous offensive numbers.
The slugger won the AL batting title with a .316 average and led the league in on-base percentage (.432), slugging percentage (.601), OPS (1.033), total bases (341), walks (109), extra base hits (77) and Baseball-Reference WAR (72). He finished second in RBIs (106) and tied for second in home runs (42), both career highs.
Alvarez was named AL Player of the Month for March/April and July and led the Majors in batting average, OBP and slugging, becoming the fourth player to lead MLB in all three categories this century, joining Aaron Judge in 2025, Miguel Cabrera in 2013 and Barry Bonds in 200.
Alvarez is the third player since 1970 to win the AL hitting title with at least 40 homers, joining Judge (2025) and Cabrera (2012-13). He was so fearsome as a hitter that he drew 33 intentional walks, breaking Jeff Bagwell’s club record of 27 in 1997. The only player in AL history with more intentional walks in a season was Judge with 36 last year.
According to Baseball Savant, Alvarez led qualified hitters in expected wOBA (.442), expected BA (.318) and expected slugging (.636), and he ranked in the 99th percentile in average exit velocity (94.4 mph).
It’s hard to make a statistically-based argument for Caminero over Alvarez, for example.
Caminero and Alvarez hit the same number of home runs, and Alvarez drove in five more. Alvarez’s OPS+ was 190, while Caminero’s was 144. Even as a DH, Alvarez outscored Caminero in both Baseball Reference’s and FanGraphs’ versions of Wins Above the Pitcher.
For Caminero, the work is more narrative driven.
The 23-year-old All-Star was the best player on the best team in the American League and helped the Rays dramatically exceed preseason expectations. His club won 98 games compared to the Astros’ 81, or in Witt’s case, the Royals’ 69.
Perhaps the strongest point in Caminero’s favor is that he started 162 games at third base, taking on the added stress of playing defense on a daily basis, while Alvarez played just 25 of his 158 games in left field. Caminero wasn’t a Gold Glove-caliber outfielder, but he improved significantly as the season went on.
And of course Caminero was one of the top five or six hitters in the AL. His 142 wRC+ was sixth best in the league behind Alvarez, Randy Arozarena, Willson Contreras, Ben Rice and Pete Alonso.
He slashed .276/.360/.524 with 42 homers and 101 RBI. He drew nearly twice as many walks (79) as he did in his full season last year (41), when he finished ninth in AL MVP voting. He struck out just 129 times, which is rare for a young hitter of his power.
In addition to Witt being one of the best players in the league, his MVP claim comes down to how much of an impact he has had on the game. .
Note that his 94 runs scored in 2026 is less than fellow finalists Yordan Alvarez (105) and Junior Caminero (100). But the crimes around them were not equally productive. Kansas City finished 22nd in the Majors with 690 runs, while its .694 OPS was lower than the Rays and Astros (.774).
This context is worth a closer look at what Witt has done in the majors.
According to Baseball-Reference, Witt took extra bases on 66.7% of his opportunities, compared to 36% for Caminero and 22.9% for Alvarez. That doesn’t include Witt’s 45 stolen bases, second most in the AL. He also drew a career-high 67 walks, creating additional opportunities to use his speed.
Witt provided his offensive production, leading qualified AL shortstops in batting average (.281), doubles (33) and slugging percentage (.441).
His contributions extended to the field, where his above-average +24 output led all Major Leaguers at the position. Despite his first career stint on the injured list, which limited him to 143 games, Witt compiled an AL-best 7.0 fWAR.
While Alvarez and Caminero made their case with offensive production, Witt’s contributions in every facet of the game offered a different perspective on what makes a player valuable.
There was a point in the middle of the summer when Crowe-Armstrong went to the scorched earth on the baseball diamond around the Majors, when there was an interesting debate about whether the Cubs’ star center fielder could overtake two-way superstar Shohei Ohtani as the National League MVP.
Was there even an argument by the end of September?
The Crow-Armstrong streak quickly flew by and turned into one of the best seasons, not just in Cubs history, but in baseball history. He finished with an MLB-leading 10.6 fWAR, putting him 3.6 WAR ahead of the Kings’ second-place finisher, Bobby Witt Jr. (7.0). Not since 1956, when Mickey Mantle outdueled Duke Snyder, had the No. 1 and No. 2 hitters in baseball had at least a 3.0 WAR difference.
Crow-Armstrong tied Kyle Schwarber for the MLB lead in home runs (45) while also tied for second in the NL in stolen bases (41). In that span, he became the seventh player in MLB history with a 40-40 season. Crow-Armstrong, Ohtani (2024) and Alfonso Soriano (2006) are the only players with at least 45 homers, 40 steals and 30 doubles in a year.
Crow-Armstrong played in all 162 games, posting a .372 on-base percentage and leading the NL in slugging (.570) and OPS (.942). He had 83 walks and 107 RBIs and led baseball with 119 runs scored. Defensively, the center fielder’s +26 fielding value set the Statcast era record for an outfielder, while his above-average +26 output tied Byron Buckton (2017) for the most by an outfielder.
By definition, he’s no more valuable than Ohtani when he’s producing as a two-way player. He had a 143 OPS+, which means he was considered 43% better than the league average offense, and hit 30 home runs with an .889 OPS. He finished with a 1.79 ERA and a 237 ERA+ in 85 2/3 elite innings.
But injuries have derailed Ohtani’s two-way season as he hasn’t appeared in a game since July 3rd. He mostly dealt with lingering left knee and right bicep issues that kept him off the mound and resulted in a season-ending collapse at the plate.
Ohtani hasn’t had the best offensive season in the NL, so the question may be how much his performance has increased his real and perceived value. No NL pitcher threw at least 80 innings and had a lower ERA than Ohtani — and none of them were their team’s starting DH. As with all things Ohtani, the case for and against him winning his fifth career MVP Award isn’t as simple as it seems. —
It’s been three years since incoming Brewers manager Pat Murphy predicted quantum leaps for Turang, and the infielder continues to take them. After rubbing shoulders with Team USA’s Aaron Judge and Bryce Harper in the World Baseball Classic, Turang hit career highs in home runs (21), RBI (100), on-base percentage (.366) and slugging percentage (.450) during the 2026 regular season. And he was at his best when it mattered most, leading the Majors in average (.361) and on-base percentage (.475) for the month of September as the Brewers secured MLB’s best record and home field advantage throughout the postseason.
A finalist, Turang will become the first Brewers player to finish in the top 3 in MVP Award voting since first baseman Prince Fielder finished third in 2011 (lefty Ryan Braun earned the honor). And Turang will become the first Brewers center fielder to finish in the top three since Robin Yount won the AL MVP Award in 1982.
“He plays every day whether he’s injured or not. He plays every day,” Murphy said of Turang. “He’s a force on the bases. He’s a force at the plate. He’ll go down when he needs to. Hit a homer. Hit a double. He’s a baseball rat. This guy loves baseball. He’s gone from a ‘good player’ to a friend this year.” —