Fast forward two years, and when the 2026 MVP winners were announced Thursday night, Henderson’s name was nowhere to be found. And it wasn’t a surprise: He posted a .225/.309/.403 slash line in ’26, almost 200 OPS points off his career high in ’24. After two years of declining offensive production, the 2023 AL Rookie of the Year isn’t a bad player, but he’s nowhere near the superstar level he once was.
While Henderson has battled injuries in each of the past two seasons — a strained left shoulder in 2025 and a right wrist problem in ’26 — there are other reasons for his decline. Here’s where Henderson struggles and how he can become an MVP-caliber player again.
There is a high correlation between top flight bat speed and offensive success. All-Star 2024, Henderson had the best bat speed in the Majors, sitting tied with Mariner Julio Rodriguez for ninth at 76.2 mph. Considered any “fast swing” with at least 75 mph, Henderson regularly swung hard and impacted the baseball.
That hasn’t been the case over the past two seasons, as Henderson’s bat speed has declined. Was 20th in MLB at 75.3 mph in 2025; His 74.1 mph bat speed in ’26 was 55th.
That’s a worrying trend, though it’s still above average and can be at least partially explained by the arm injuries that have plagued him over the past two years. But without that elite bat speed, Henderson struggles to make as solid contact. His strikeout rate per swing — a measure of how much potential exit velocity is being achieved — dropped from 25.1% in both 2024 and ’25 to just 22.6% in 2026.
To say that Henderson needs to recapture the excellent bat speed he once possessed is easier said than done. But Henderson, who will be 25 on Opening Day 2027, is just entering his prime and should be able to regain some of his lost strength with good health.
Henderson’s decline in bat speed is at least part of the reason the Orioles shortstop will struggle significantly against fastballs in 2026. After hitting .305 with a .444 slugging percentage against heaters in 2025, Henderson hit just .233 against fastballs with a .401 SLG. Especially against four-seamers, he hit just .169 with a .291 SLG, good for a -11 run value that was tied for ninth-worst in the Majors.
Interestingly, it wasn’t a top speed control issue: Henderson was slightly better against the 95+ mph heat than the four sailors below 95 mph. This could be the result of a slight change in his position in the batter’s box from 2024-26.
Henderson’s starting depth in the batter’s box, 2024-26
2024: 24.9 inches
2025: 26.7 inches
2026: 27.7 inches
Henderson can make things right in 2026 by once again using the poorly pitched fastballs he used to crush. After hitting a below-average 79.7% of his fastballs in his first four seasons, he’s struck out just 90 of 143 such heaters in 2026 (62.9%). That rate ranked 19th lowest among 288 batters to see at least 50 medium-to-medium fastballs in 2026, a sign of Henderson’s declining aggressiveness.
Henderson’s reluctance to swing at the meatball was one of the most obvious signs of a poor season in terms of plate discipline, which previously didn’t bother the rising star much.
While his 22.2% strikeout rate was on par with his 2024 mark of 22.1%, the problem ran deeper than K’s. Not only did Henderson throw impressive pitches, but he also proved prone to expanding the strike zone, pushing his strikeout rate to a career-worst 30.4% and falling below league average in that category for the first time in his career. By comparison, his 23.2% strikeout rate in ’24 ranked in the 84th percentile in MLB.
At the end of the season, Henderson told MLB.com’s Jake Rill that he felt he was “doing too much in certain situations” or “trying to make things happen,” assessments that helped explain his underwhelming season at the plate.
Tightening up his approach and becoming more selective once again could go a long way toward getting Henderson back among MLB’s top hitters.
Even without hitting the offensive limit, Henderson remains a valuable player: According to Statcast, he was an above-average baseman (+3 run value) and a plus defender by Outs Above Average (+1) in 2026. Henderson had 4.8 FanGraphs WAR in 2025 and 3.6 fWAR in ’26, so he remains one of the best everyday players in the big leagues.
Amassing an MVP-caliber 7.9 fWAR in 2024, Henderson is capable of much more with the bat clicking. A big offensive year from him could do wonders for the rest of the Orioles lineup and propel the team toward the postseason, and Baltimore is hoping for the best for its star shortstop in 2027.
“I fully expect him to have a better season this year,” Orioles president of baseball operations Mike Elias said at this week’s GM Meetings in Las Vegas. “We will certainly do everything we can to work with his camp and support his development in the offseason.
“He’ll be back in the saddle.”